Is My KH3 Ending Theory Plausible?

[NezzyGuda 2]

I believe Kingdom Hearts 3 will end with the death of all 7 Guardians of Light...

 

...Okay well maybe not "dead" dead, but here me out...

 

 

There has been a lot of chatter that the 5 "Lost Masters" are actually:

[it is believed these are the lost masters due to color scheme comparison, height equivalents, and the use of the same voice actors, I would recommend looking into this more yourself if your skeptical (Rebirth Theory w/ Pics = http://forums.khinsider.com/kingdom-hearts-iii/194630-rebirth.html and GamersJoint voice comparison https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8rGI_Yzr2cI ]

Aqua = Anguis

Ventus = Leopardos

Riku = Unicornis

Terra = Ursus

Kairi = Vulpeus

 

...with the sixth lost master being missing

 

It is also believed that the missing final page in the Book of Prophecies is also the page that states that darkness will triumph over light...

 

Now here's where my theory begins, what if the Book of Prophecies was written by "people" from the future in order to try to prevent the outcome these "people" had faced (darkness defeating light)? So as to say, the Book of Prophecies is actually less of a prophecy written by the foretellers, but more of a recollection of past events the foretellers/"lost masters" actually experienced? This would mean that the "people" who wrote the Book of Prophecies only knew what happened up to the point of darkness defeating light, NOT what happened afterwards. I emphasize this because it seems as though the Book of Prophecies is incomplete and limited (the prophecy ends at a point that I can't possibly see as being the ending) and I think that's because its not the ending, but rather, just as far as the "lost masters" were able to make it before getting sent back in time! (Maybe through the power of finally achieving Kingdom Hearts) Now I want to quickly focus on the term "LOST masters". What makes the masters "LOST" and if the Lost Masters are the Foretellers, why are the Foretellers LOST??? I believe its because after the great war/clash between the 13 SoD and 7 GoL, 6 keyblade masters in the fight disappeared, not to a new location, but to a different time. So what if, at the end of Kingdom Hearts 3, Xehanort had finally captured Kingdom Hearts and the world fell to darkness, but as this happened, somehow Aqua, Ventus, Terra, Riku, and Kairi were sent back in time (along with the other unknown master) and became the foretellers.

 

 

[Here's where the theory becomes a bit difficult to explain since we dont know who the GoL or the missing foreteller is, soooo from this point it's more random speculation than a theory backed by context clues]

 

The crazy thing here is that Mickey, Axel/Lea, Sora, and Xehanort (not accounting for Vanitas, as I believe he may be defeated prior to this point) are all unaccounted for. I speculate that it could be possible that Mickey, Axel/Lea, and Sora are presumed dead by Xehanort, who finally achieves Kingdom Hearts. I speculate Sora and Axel/Lea "die" first. Then Mickey, in a last ditch effort, somehow manages to send Aqua, Ventus, Riku, Terra, and Kairi to the past to prevent the future, and "dies" doing so. Thinking they are all dead, and knowing the 5 were sent into the past, Xehanort goes into the past as the 6th/final foreteller(lost master) to steal the page from the foretellers as an attempt to prevent the world from knowing the truth that the events in the Book of Prophecies would lead to Xehanort's victory (so as to prevent anyone that were to read the full Book of Prophecies from ruining his plans). This would allow him to orchestrate a long drawn out plan manipulating even his younger self into following in his footsteps by mentoring Young Eraquas and Young Xehanort as his pupils. He would then use his ability to time travel to points in which he existed to return to the battlefield at the end of the game to finally sit on his throne ruling over the darkness in the world. However, I believe Axel/Lea will have died shielding Sora again (but this time he dies for real), and Mickey isn't dead but seriously injured and can't move. This would leave Sora and Xehanort to battle it out for one final showdown after the annihilation of the entire crew, the Book of Prophecies to have been fulfilled and for the Xehanort saga to be entirely tied up of loose ends. This would also account for Sora continuing on in his journey in the next installations of the game as the main character (as Nomura had stated would be the case) and would leave Kingdom Hearts X as more of a "side story" with the final page within the book of prophecies to actually be fully canon (which is what Nomura had stated would be the case of Kingdom Hearts X in relation to KH3). I also recall Hashimoto or Nomura, earlier in KH3's development, saying that they planned to make the ending sad, but Disney told them it was too sad and that they wanted a happier ending. And I believe this ending is sad enough for Disney to speculate it.

 

 

 

OKAY SO WHAT DO YOU GUYS THINK?

Do you guys think this is plausible?

Do you think this makes a lot of sense but maybe a little different? (such as Axel/Lea actually being the 6th Lost Master, but is Killed by Xehanort and framed as a rebellious lost master?) (Or even the 6 Lost Masters are the 7 Guardians of Light minus Sora?)

Am I missing anything such as the use of the X-blade in KH3?

Is there anything you'd add or subtract from this theory?

 

Please let me know!! ^_^

[KingdomHearts3 2,591]

No no no! This is the rebirth theory that does not make any sense! The Foretellers have not been reincarnated as Ventus, Terra, Aqua, Riku, and Kairi and Master Xehanort is not the reincarnation of the 6th APPRENTICE, not Foreteller. What also doesn't make sense is the theory of the death of the seven. How can they die if Sora is going to be the protagonist of the series after KH3? Nomura said he will so this does not make sense. The lost masters are most likely the Foretellers since they started the Keyblade War. Lea is not one of the seven too because Yen Sid has said in 0.2 that we need to summon Ventus, Terra, and Aqua. He is no lost master either. Also, the seven and thirteen did not exist during and before the Keyblade War and in the theory of yours, you basically disregarded that portion.

 

I will say that this theory is absolutely not plausible, but nice try though.

Edited January 4, 2016 by KingdomHearts3

[NezzyGuda 2]

No no no! This is the rebirth theory that does not make any sense! The Foretellers have not been reincarnated as Ventus, Terra, Aqua, Riku, and Kairi and Master Xehanort is not the reincarnation of the 6th APPRENTICE, not Foreteller. What also doesn't make sense is the theory of the death of the seven. How can they die if Sora is going to be the protagonist of the series after KH3? Nomura said he will so this does not make sense. The lost masters are most likely the Foretellers since they started the Keyblade War. Lea is not one of the seven too because Yen Sid has said in 0.2 that we need to summon Ventus, Terra, and Aqua. He is no lost master either. Also, the seven and thirteen did not exist during and before the Keyblade War and in the theory of yours, you basically disregarded that portion.I will say that this theory is absolutely not plausible, but nice try though.

i feel like you didnt read the theory lol

[Seyin95 175]

I applaud you for trying; I'm all for people creating their own theories; however kh3 is the last in the Xehanort Saga; therefore your ending would create too many loopholes and it wouldn't be a satisfying ending; yes this game will be dark and have mature themes; and yes it is plausible Xehanort will be successful, but to have the GOLs ' die' then sent to the past essentially means the series will be one massive loop and there is no way Disney will let anything bad happen to Mickey after all he is their mascot. Also in terms of people like Riku/Aqua etc they have huge fan bases and if your theory is correct then that essentially rules them out of future installments which will alienate a lot of people; also what would be the point of saving these people if their fate is only to go back in time? Also how do you explain the likely return of characters such as Roxas/Xion/Namine etc?

 

I do think some of your ending is plausible and indeed likely; such as Xehanort being successful; a Sora vs Xehanort showdown etc however from a gaming perspective and I'm sure others will agree we want a satisfying ending which leaves us with no unanswered questions, I sadly don't think this would provide that

 

Ps I think the game you're thinking of regarding Disney changing an ending to a games is BBS, makes you wonder what on earth they planned if it was darker? Haha

[KingdomHearts3 2,591]

i feel like you didnt read the theory lol

I did and it is not much different from the rebirth theory that has become unreasonably popular. I did see what separates yours from the rebirth theory though and addressed it.

[Gwynbleidd 551]

Disney really doesn't like death all too greatly. I doubt the main protagonists, especially all of them, would "die".

[The Transcendent Key 12,109]

While your theory is quite interesting and pretty good, there's one thing you need to consider: Young Xehanort clearly stated in Dream Drop Distance that when it comes to time travel, events that are destined to happen cannot be changed, so traveling back to the past is definitely a no go.  The Keyblade War is something that inevitably happens, the prophecy is something that inevitably happens, and everything else that has happened in the series has all been the work of destiny and Xehanort's machinations!

 

Honestly, I wouldn't like it if Kingdom Hearts III ended with everything that's happened in the series becoming non-existent, ya know?  Because if they travel back in time to prevent all this disaster, then that means that everything in the series so far will have happened for nothing!  So yeah, I don't think time traveling is the solution here.

 

And also, I prefer to think of Riku, Kairi, Aqua, Terra and Ventus as descendants of the Foretellers instead of reincarnations, ya know?  But yeah, that's a pretty good theory you have there!

Edited January 15, 2016 by The Transcendent Key