Are the princesses of heart subject to change?

[Isamu Kuno 2,512]

  On 8/27/2015 at 6:03 PM, WakingDawn96 said:

But what happens when a child is born from a Princess of Heart? What would that make the child?

Just a normal Princess

[Hero of Light XIV 2,381]

  On 8/27/2015 at 3:22 PM, LETTERSE7EN said:

Of course it doesnt..but one can only hope

Well, sorry if not all the Princesses of Heart are your favorite Disney Princesses, but that's just how it is. BTW, Alice may not be Disney Royalty, but she is a part of the Disney Princess line in terms of marketing. Most female heroines in Disney movies tend to be part of the Princess line, while those that actually have any sort of Royal status are also part of the Royalty line. So while Alice might not be Disney Royalty, she IS a Disney "Princess" in the sense that she is a female protagonist that girls can identify with and buy products of. They also went with some of the more iconic ones to start with, and Alice is pretty iconic. This also helped with the red herring of the story that Wendy might have been a princess, seeing as they are both not members of royalty but were female protagonists, not to mention visitors of another world.

[Dave 5,715]

  On 8/27/2015 at 3:06 PM, LETTERSE7EN said:

 

 I'd be surprised if Frozen doesn't appear as well (although Anna might have too much personality to became one of them).

 

[Guest]

Maybe, just maybe, there may be a new set of princesses. A category where Ariel, Mulan, Tiana, Rapunzel, Anna, Elsa, Moana etc. can be categorised in. Princesses that have an equally valuable element to them, I dunno, something like the "Princess Of Dreams" that maintains the balance of light and darkness?

[LETTERSE7EN 54]

I mean, I know you can't change the princesses, I didn't really take this post very seriously. Just saying I don't want to see Wonderland again (not that Alice's presence would mean wonderland was a must, but yeah)...then I thought about Kairi and how her being a key blade wielder might have an effect on her position as a princess of heart..

 

Im fully well aware that you don't need to be royalty to be a princess of heart..just thought it was weird to throw Alice instead of ariel, especially since they both existed in the same game

[Guest]

  On 8/28/2015 at 1:30 PM, LETTERSE7EN said:

I mean, I know you can't change the princesses, I didn't really take this post very seriously. Just saying I don't want to see Wonderland again (not that Alice's presence would mean wonderland was a must, but yeah)...then I thought about Kairi and how her being a key blade wielder might have an effect on her position as a princess of heart..Im fully well aware that you don't need to be royalty to be a princess of heart..just thought it was weird to throw Alice instead of ariel, especially since they both existed in the same game

 

Maybe because Ariel was a mermaid and that she was manipulated by Ursula which meant Ariel was willing to dabble with Darkness prevent her from being a Princess Of Heart?

[Jiminy's Journal 13]

  On 8/27/2015 at 3:52 PM, WakingDawn96 said:

Now hang on people, does anybody else remember this? http://onceuponatimeabc.wikia.com/wiki/File:Regina_217.pngSnow White's heart did have a touch of darkness in it at one point, so things can change for even the princesses of heart if they let their hearts give into darkness. Which means that I don't know if Snow could be considered a princess of heart anymore, which would mean we have an opening in the roster here!(But seriously, I don't know how this works exactly. But I am actually okay with the princesses of heart we have already. But wasn't Aqua supposed to be a princess of heart until Kairi took her place since Aqua fell into darkness? Maybe it changes between every generation?)

It cleared up by season 3B.https://youtu.be/v4VXCJ5_Cbk?t=39shttp://kissthemgoodbye.net/onceuponatime/displayimage.php?album=58&pid=126007

Edited August 29, 2015 by Jiminy's Journal

[WakingDawn96 1,166]

  On 8/29/2015 at 8:09 PM, Jiminy's Journal said:

It cleared up by season 3B.

http://kissthemgoodbye.net/onceuponatime/displayimage.php?album=58&pid=126007

Well I know that, I have seen ever episode that has released and I am waiting for the next season to begin. But anyways, a princess of heart doesn't have darkness in their heart ever so even though it cleared up, I don't know if Snow should be counted as total light anymore! But anyways, that is enough of my joke here and my talk of Once!

[Robbie the Wise 5,050]

  On 8/29/2015 at 9:41 PM, WakingDawn96 said:

Well I know that, I have seen ever episode that has released and I am waiting for the next season to begin. But anyways, a princess of heart doesn't have darkness in their heart ever so even though it cleared up, I don't know if Snow should be counted as total light anymore! But anyways, that is enough of my joke here and my talk of Once!

You keep saying you're joking yet you keep trying to correlate Once Upon A Time with Kingdom Hearts when the two series are completely unrelated and in no way canon to one another. I don't think you're joking at all it just seems like you're back pedaling. Edited August 29, 2015 by RobbyRobRob the Wise

[WakingDawn96 1,166]

  On 8/29/2015 at 9:54 PM, RobbyRobRob the Wise said:

You keep saying you're joking yet you keep trying to correlate Once Upon A Time with Kingdom Hearts when the two series are completely unrelated and in no way canon to one another. I don't think you're joking at all it just seems like you're back pedaling.

I think you all miss the point, the point is Once and KH have similarities (don't try and say "Well they don't have any similarities, total different use of characters and plot elements!" They may not be canon to each other, but they have similarities and you guys need to stop yelling at me, watch Once and play KH near each other and realize that they are similar! I don't care if you haters are going to hate on Once, you can at least notice similarities. 

Edited August 29, 2015 by Flaming Lea
rude

[Robbie the Wise 5,050]

  On 8/29/2015 at 11:18 PM, WakingDawn96 said:

I think you all miss the point, the point is Once and KH have similarities (don't try and say "Well they don't have any similarities, total different use of characters and plot elements!" They may not be canon to each other, but they have similarities and you guys need to stop yelling at me, watch Once and play KH near each other and realize that they are similar! I don't care if you haters are going to hate on Once, you can at least notice similarities. 

 I didn't yell at you in the slightest if that's your idea of yelling the internet is not for you. All I pointed out was that for all their similarities the two series are distinct from one another and in no way have canon impact on each other's stories. When people have pointed this out you play it off like you're joking then proceed to argue that one impacts the other when it doesn't. Also no one in this thread is hating on the show so what's even the point of bringing that up.

[Ephemera 37]

  On 8/27/2015 at 3:06 PM, LETTERSE7EN said:

If I'm not mistaken, our princesses are: Alice, Cinderella, Aurora, Snow White, Jasmine, Belle, and Kairi. Im not particularly a fan of Alice being one of them being that she's not a princess...like at all. And yet Ariel (who IS a princess) was not one of them. I dont care for Alice mainly because i don't want to see Wonderland again unless some serious changes are made. i think Jane might have made a better princess but whatever, who am I?

 

Anyway, In the KH3 we have already confirmed Rapunzel (yet another princess) is set to appear. I'd be surprised if Frozen doesn't appear as well (although Anna might have too much personality to became one of them). Do you think it's possible to have a different set of princesses or is that roster pretty much set in stone? Maybe now that Kairi is a keyblade wielder it changes things. Anyway, if it were up to me (I am aware that it isn't), my princess would be:

 

Jasmine, Belle, Anna, Rapunzel, Cinderella, Ariel, and Aurora...yeah i got rid of snow, its a personal thing.

 

i was also thinking about this. Unless new information reveals that its possible for titles to interchange, then perhaps. especially since the guardians of light and seekers of darkness are interchangeable. 

[LETTERSE7EN 54]

  On 8/27/2015 at 5:18 PM, Kaweebo said:

 

I know, you're absolutley right..like I said, it's personal..Ive always disliked her. Either way it's not too big a deal, it's not like the princesses play so much of a significant role that they get hours worth of screen time..I'm not saying they're insignificant, just that I dont have to see them often enough for them to really annoy me..

 

Seriously though, what? Out of all the POH to remove and you picked the one who fit the bill the most?

Sorry, i did that last post on my phone and messed that quote up terribly..

[Philip Ellwell 5,487]

None of the other Disney princesses are pure enough to be a PoH: The 7 originals are truly blameless for anything in their stories, but others have done stuff to give them possibly a tiny shred of darkness, like Rapunzel setting off on her own and endangering herself, (Needed for the plot, I know, but it could be seen as a bad/self destructive choice), Anna is out for several reasons, and Ariel not only disobeyed her parent, but also nearly got him killed. 

All Aurora did was prick her finger. Snow White ran a bit. Belle..kinda did nothing even remotely bad. Alice is more honorary due to being 100% blameless: all she did was follow a dumb rabbit. 

Plus the 7 PoH are kinda already set in stone, and they haven't been in the plot much lately as keys to the Door of Darkness, so I doubt more will be added. 

And the other "Princesses" that are simply females of non-royal birth considered princesses by fans (Esmerelda, Jane, Wendy, Sally) are kind off the table as probably not being pure enough, or, as i've noticed, not being part of the classic age of Disney. Except for Kairi, all the PoH are from highly regarded Disney clasics. 

This got longer than I'd intended...