Namine or Xion?

[Amon 4,279]

Hitler would approve of Namine with Roxas...

 

Think about it for a second...

[King Riku 2,063]

Namine and Roxas should be together, Roxas being Sor's Nobody and Namine being Kairi's. Plus they are so cute together <3

[luckey charm 0]

well yes R+N r better but it's kinda like xion and namine r the same nobody, because namine is kairi's nobody, but xion was made from sora's srong's memorie's witch is kairi, so it's kinda like if xion had a person it would be kairi so it's a little cofusing but it would go good ether way!

 

 

confusing yet?

[Soul Eater Evans 4,045]

 

Namine, its kinda creepy if it was Xion cuz its like dating your sister since its they are both part of the same person

 

Actually, dating Namine is more like dating your sister. She and Roxas were born at the same time from the same person after all. Dating Xion is more like extreme narcissism.

 

This aint cool.Time for the tie bracker8)

Many of you are constantly arguing over RoxasXnamine or RoxasXxion but really..... it comes down to choice.TECHNICALLY Roxas' sister's are namine and Xion because Roxas and Namine came from Sora and Xion came from Roxas (correct me if im wrong but its somewhat like that)

SOOOOo.........techincally,either couple is incest.It really comes down to choice on this one.They both had great times with eachother and I really just cant choose.Well.......(dont hate me for this) KairiXRoxas is always an open couple since the two didn't come from one another plus Roxas has memories of Kairi so we could say he has a crush on her.What saddens me is that Roxas only talked to Kairi once....... telepathically.

 

*Yawn* I'm just trying to stop the arguing.

[luckey charm 0]

yeah actually where did the fight come from? i gess people just though about it and someone went crazy!

[Soul Eater Evans 4,045]

yeah actually where did the fight come from? i gess people just though about it and someone went crazy!

 

This is not cool.More like over obssessed fan boy/girls arguing about Roxas' gf.Tsk,tsk tsk.

[luckey charm 0]

yeah

[Tails 6,690]

I say Roxas is better off with Namine. Roxas dating Xion is like dating yourself... in a sense.

[HeartofFire 10]

Neither. To me, they're both like his sisters.

[Zenithia 305]

To me, if ignore how all three came into existence, I would choose Xion. Roxas ultimately spent the longest time with Xion, caring for her well being and so forth, and even going so far as to defend her when Saix called Xion an it. Namine spent little time with Roxas, though mostly like somewhat of a mentor to help him reuse the keyblade. I would have a hard time believing that Roxas would fall for someone he just met so quickly, but oh well. Roxas did shed a tear when Xion disappeared from the aftermath of their battle. And even going after Xemnas in order to see, and maybe be with, Xion again.

[Reversal 53]

I like the interaction Roxas and Xion had, and their relationship felt much more fleshed out compared with Namine's seemingly instant obsession with Roxas surfacing that was never shown in Days. However, with Days being oh so guilty of making Roxas and Riku especially out of character, it leaves a bad taste in my mouth. Roxas went from being this badass mysterious kid who lef the the Organization to discover the truth about himself, to an annoying whiny Xion fanboy who did everything for her sake and her alone.

 

Overall, I prefer how they developed Roxas and Xion's relationship, but I like the Roxas/Namine pairing better. Which makes me start to think; since Xion became Roxas' Kairi instead of Namine, what'd happen to their relationship, once the memories of Xion return? How would Namine feel, to be left out and alone again? Just something random that came into my head.

[deathrebirthsenshi 279]

I say Xion. Roxas didn't really know Namine; the only time he met her was the beginning of KH2, right? I now that it's kind of implied because Namine is Kairi and Roxas is Sora, but in the end I like Xion with him better.

 

And with all the people talking about the technicalities, please stop. You are ruining my fan pairings! lol

[RoxasStalker 11]

I honestly can't stand video game pairings, but if I had to chose I'd say Xion.

 

Seriously, Namine and Roxas hardly knew each other but they act like a couple at the end of KHII -_-

Xion on the other hand, was with Roxas a lot and she was even the reason that he left the Organization(kinda) and they did seem veeeeeeery close *wink wink nudge nudge*

 

And what's this about Roxas being an annoying whiny Xion fanboy? Roxas is still totally badass in Days.

[Tails 6,690]

I like the interaction Roxas and Xion had, and their relationship felt much more fleshed out compared with Namine's seemingly instant obsession with Roxas surfacing that was never shown in Days. However, with Days being oh so guilty of making Roxas and Riku especially out of character, it leaves a bad taste in my mouth. Roxas went from being this badass mysterious kid who lef the the Organization to discover the truth about himself, to an annoying whiny Xion fanboy who did everything for her sake and her alone.

 

Overall, I prefer how they developed Roxas and Xion's relationship, but I like the Roxas/Namine pairing better. Which makes mn to their relationship, once the memories of Xion return? How would Namine feel, to be lefte start to think; since Xion became Roxas' Kairi instead of Namine, what'd happe out and alone again? Just something random that came into my head.

Very true, he did spend most of her time with Xion more than he did with namine. i mean, he only met Naminie for like 7 days, while he was with Xion for like a year. Namine never had an "obsession" with Roxas in Days. She was mainly focused on trying to get Xion to return back with Sora, so she mostly payed more attention to Xion more than Roxas. And we already found out more about Riku in CoM/Re:CoM, i don't see what more we could possibly know about him other than the fact that he is trying to controll the darkness inside him, working with DiZ, and help trying to restore Sora's memories. Ans since when did Roxas become a "Xion fanboy"? You gotta remember,Axel and Xion was basicly the only to friends he ever made during the time he spent in the Organization. so of course he's gonna go all emo all because Xion "died". She and Axel were the only friends he ever had in his life. At least until he met data versions of Hayner, pence, and Olette. then he started being all obsessive about them.

 

Also, it is true that both namine and Xion play the "kairi" role around roxas. but it seems that he will focus more on Namine than he will to Xion. i mean, he forgot all about Xion in the end of Days. So it's more than likly that he won't give too much of a crap about Xion.

[RoxasStalker 11]

 

I like the interaction Roxas and Xion had, and their relationship felt much more fleshed out compared with Namine's seemingly instant obsession with Roxas surfacing that was never shown in Days. However, with Days being oh so guilty of making Roxas and Riku especially out of character, it leaves a bad taste in my mouth. Roxas went from being this badass mysterious kid who lef the the Organization to discover the truth about himself, to an annoying whiny Xion fanboy who did everything for her sake and her alone.

 

Overall, I prefer how they developed Roxas and Xion's relationship, but I like the Roxas/Namine pairing better. Which makes mn to their relationship, once the memories of Xion return? How would Namine feel, to be lefte start to think; since Xion became Roxas' Kairi instead of Namine, what'd happe out and alone again? Just something random that came into my head.

Very true, he did spend most of her time with Xion more than he did with namine. i mean, he only met Naminie for like 7 days, while he was with Xion for like a year. Namine never had an "obsession" with Roxas in Days. She was mainly focused on trying to get Xion to return back with Sora, so she mostly payed more attention to Xion more than Roxas. And we already found out more about Riku in CoM/Re:CoM, i don't see what more we could possibly know about him other than the fact that he is trying to controll the darkness inside him, working with DiZ, and help trying to restore Sora's memories. Ans since when did Roxas become a "Xion fanboy"? You gotta remember,Axel and Xion was basicly the only to friends he ever made during the time he spent in the Organization. so of course he's gonna go all emo all because Xion "died". She and Axel were the only friends he ever had in his life. At least until he met data versions of Hayner, pence, and Olette. then he started being all obsessive about them.

 

Also, it is true that both namine and Xion play the "kairi" role around roxas. but it seems that he will focus more on Namine than he will to Xion. i mean, he forgot all about Xion in the end of Days. So it's more than likly that he won't give too much of a crap about Xion.

 

This made me grin like a moron for some reason.

[Kamrin DiSandro 2]

I have to say this in both a logical yet fan way. I will say Roxas and Xion and here are the reasons why.

 

1. They actually spend time for each other. During 358/2 days. It also showed that Roxas showed a lot more consent over Xion. Even though he did for Namine it was only for advice.

 

2. Yes I know Namine is Kairi's nobody which is the only reason why Roxas likes her. Namine didn't show along of memories of being Kairi. Now granted neither did Xion, but since she is Sora's memories of Kairi that means she what's more similarities.

 

3. They both can take care of themselves as well as each other. When Namine was grabbed by Ansem the Wise in Kingdom Hearts 2. She was draged in. When all she could do was open a portal to speak to Roxas again. Which means she only was looking after Roxas. Remember this though she was asked to look after Roxas by Xion. Cause she knew as soon as she was gonna Roxas would have closed himself.

 

4. Namine looked like she was more interested in Riku then Roxas. Think of it Roxas was helping the organization collect hearts. While what was Namine and Riku doing after Chain of Memories.

 

5. Roxas and Xion got along much better then Roxas and Namine did. Think of it Roxas and Namine got like five scenes together. Where Roxas and Xion hanged out thought a whole game.

 

6. Its also establishes that not all characters have to end up with he first girl introduced series wised (KH1FM, KH2FM, KHRCOM, KH358/2 Days, KHBBSFM, KHRC, KHDDD, and KH3FM) cause we have see a character end up with the second girl. (You can thank Naruto for that.)

 

If it makes it fair to Roxas and Namine fans there are a few flaws that could get the Roxas and Namine together.

 

1. After Xion dissapeared everyone she knew forgot about her. Even Roxas.

 

2. Even if they could bring Xion Back. There are both apart of Sora which makes them related. It would be like a brother dating his sister.

 

3. If Sora does manage to bring Roxas back that still wouldn't mean Xion would be brought back too. Because Xion isn't really a nobody she is Sora's memories.

 

4. Even if they both come back they still wouldn't remeber each other.

 

So I think it will be up with the writers, but for my KH Pairings it would be. Sora X Kairi, Riku X Namine, Roxas, X Xion, and Terra X Aqua. Maybe theyll make a love interest for Ventus and Lea in future instalments. But let's stick to that.

[Stellar Mage 2]

I say XionxRoxas all the way! I hate it when people say namine just cuz they would look cute together! Just cuz thier somebodies are soon-to-be. I also hate it when people say that it's like he is dating himself. Once they were the same being but once they separated from Sora they were different people. It's like saying they were never they're own person. They had thier own feelings, thoughts, and personalities too! Namine and Roxas? I have nothing against namine but her with roxas? They barely knew each other! And they probably wouldnt have met if not for Xion. Xion and Roxas makes more sense. they instantly were interested in each other.(not tht way. they just were but im not sure in what way) . They were best friends. Xion gave her existance away and everyone forgot about her. Roxas tried to hold on. But (thxs to riku) he forgot in the end. and she knew it would happen but she did it cuz she thought it was for the good of everyone. Namine only met Roxas briefly and automatically people thought they should get together because of kairi and sora, So my answer to this question must be Xion.

 

 

[The Transcendent Key 12,109]

I personally think that Roxas would be better off with Xion!  The reason?  Well, even though he lost his memory of her the moment she died, the year they spent together was a year filled with hardships, obstacles and many sad moments.  But there were happy moments too!  And after witnessing the events of Days, I knew that Roxas and Xion were meant to be!  I mean sure, Namine is great and all too, but Roxas and Xion went through so much more together!  Gahhh...the feels!

[mag77 405]

I pretty much agree with everything Stellar Mage said.  It gets really annoying when people think that Roxas and Namine should be together because Sora and Kairi are 'together' (do people realize that Sora and Kairi aren't even a couple yet?)  Even if Sora and Kairi get together, that doesn't mean their Nobodies should.  This is like saying a guy and a girl get together, and it just so happens they both have identical twins.  Well, since they're together, then their twins should get together too. That's just really stupid, and it treats the twins like they're the same person.  Just as identical twins are still two separate people with their own personalities, Sora and Roxas are different from one another, and so are Kairi and Namine. 

 

Not only that, but Roxas and Xion spent almost a whole year getting to know each other and became friends, while Roxas and Namine only spent maybe an hour total talking to one another.  Sorry, but Roxas x Xion all the way!

[Hallowseve 143]

Now, I don't typically involve myself in "shipping", but I think Roxas and Namine make more sense. We all know Roxas is the Nobody of Sora and Namine is the Nobody of Kairi. It's heavily implied that Sora has romantic feelings for Kairi, and vice versa. It kind of makes sense like that, It'd be Sora x Kairi and Roxas x Namine (almost like a mirror)... I know understanding it proves to be a challenge.

 

When it comes to Xion, I always see her being with Riku. It's slightly implied in KH1 that Riku likes Kairi, too. So why not form a relationship with her "Sora/Roxas' replica/memories"? Plus if Riku x Xion were a thing, it would shut up the insane supporters of Riku x Sora. Riku would practically be dating Sora, albeit female version.

 

My post probably makes zero sense, but I hope someone can figure out what I'm saying.

[Vandalia1998 0]

On 8/4/2010 at 5:45 PM, JTD95 said:

Namine is Roxas Twiligth Town GF

Xion is Roxas Organization GF

Kind of Like Namine is Sora’s Castle Oblivion Girlfriend 

and Kairi is his Main Series Girlfriend 

[Jennifer Chen 1]

On 8/4/2010 at 5:45 PM, JTD95 said:

Naminé is Roxas Twilight Town GF

Xion is Roxas Organization GF

No, 358/2 Days Establishes Roxas and Xion's Relationship to be more Sisterly Figure Type. Honestly, I don't mind The Naminé x Roxas Romantic Relationship But Sora and Kairi is The Worst Development Because these two should have been Sisterly Figure as well.

 

Also, In KH3 Naminé and Roxas still think of Each Other Such as When Sora arrived in The Final World She appeared as a Star He said that Roxas "misses her too" Excluding Everyone Else. I'm pretty sure That was meant to imply his Deep Romantic Feelings for her, Also Roxas was with Her in Destiny Islands but Was TOO Shy to be Around her. After Naminé heard about Roxas "missing" her, She giggled I could only assume She was blushing when she heard about Roxas.

On 11/25/2010 at 11:44 AM, heartless101 said:

He was probably better off with Namine, but I liked the pairing with Roxas and Xion

Roxas and Xion are more of a Sibling Type Relationship shown in 358/2 Days and KH3

Roxas and Naminé back in Kingdom Hearts 2 Was more Romantic Interest, He also wanted to be with her at The End of KH2.

Even After Years apart, In KH3 Roxas still has those Romantic Feelings for Naminé Such as when Sora was in the Final World and told her how much He misses her dearly. As you can see, It proves Their Feelings for Each Other are STILL There.

[jbmasta 67]

To be honest, identity matters aside collectively the three have spent fewer than five years existing by the end of Kingdom Hearts 3. Despite everything they've been through they're still emotionally children (by his own personal experience of time Roxas still associates friendship with ice cream specifically) and need time to find their own identities separate from Sora and Kairi before any possible matching up is done.

[Jennifer Chen 1]

On 1/24/2015 at 5:01 PM, Kamrin DiSandro said:

I have to say this in both a logical yet fan way. I will say Roxas and Xion and here are the reasons why.

 

1. They actually spend time for each other. During 358/2 days. It also showed that Roxas showed a lot more consent over Xion. Even though he did for Namine it was only for advice.

 

2. Yes I know Namine is Kairi's nobody which is the only reason why Roxas likes her. Namine didn't show along of memories of being Kairi. Now granted neither did Xion, but since she is Sora's memories of Kairi that means she what's more similarities.

 

3. They both can take care of themselves as well as each other. When Namine was grabbed by Ansem the Wise in Kingdom Hearts 2. She was draged in. When all she could do was open a portal to speak to Roxas again. Which means she only was looking after Roxas. Remember this though she was asked to look after Roxas by Xion. Cause she knew as soon as she was gonna Roxas would have closed himself.

 

4. Namine looked like she was more interested in Riku then Roxas. Think of it Roxas was helping the organization collect hearts. While what was Namine and Riku doing after Chain of Memories.

 

5. Roxas and Xion got along much better then Roxas and Namine did. Think of it Roxas and Namine got like five scenes together. Where Roxas and Xion hanged out thought a whole game.

 

6. Its also establishes that not all characters have to end up with he first girl introduced series wised (KH1FM, KH2FM, KHRCOM, KH358/2 Days, KHBBSFM, KHRC, KHDDD, and KH3FM) cause we have see a character end up with the second girl. (You can thank Naruto for that.)

 

If it makes it fair to Roxas and Namine fans there are a few flaws that could get the Roxas and Namine together.

 

1. After Xion dissapeared everyone she knew forgot about her. Even Roxas.

 

2. Even if they could bring Xion Back. There are both apart of Sora which makes them related. It would be like a brother dating his sister.

 

3. If Sora does manage to bring Roxas back that still wouldn't mean Xion would be brought back too. Because Xion isn't really a nobody she is Sora's memories.

 

4. Even if they both come back they still wouldn't remeber each other.

 

So I think it will be up with the writers, but for my KH Pairings it would be. Sora X Kairi, Riku X Namine, Roxas, X Xion, and Terra X Aqua. Maybe theyll make a love interest for Ventus and Lea in future instalments. But let's stick to that.

Worst Deduction For The Pairings, Recoded Chain of Memories 358/2 Days All Take Place Before Kingdom Hearts 2. According to What I remember in Roxas Scenes with Xion, He thinks of Her as a Sisterly Figure Rather than a Girlfriend. It's so obvious When You focus on How He treats her, With Naminé in Kingdom Hearts 2 Roxas takes Romantic Interest in her sorta like "Love at First Sight" Thing and He wanted to stay with her at The End.

We also see in Kingdom Hearts 3 Where Their Roxas's Romantic Feelings For Naminé are still there, He feels The Same Affection for her from Kingdom Hearts 2. Even Sora noticed This Which is Why he told Her that Roxas misses her Dearly, He was implying His Feelings for her and Based on Naminé giggling reaction I could only assume If she were in Physical Form would be blushing Hearing of him After Not Seeing Roxas in person. (She probably STILL Feels something for him like in KH2) It's simple, They Loved Each Other as soon as They met.

Roxas was also TOO Shy to Confess his Love for Naminé at the Ending of KH3 When They were on Destiny Islands, He didn't EVEN Have the Courage to Approach Her.

[JTD95 1,107]

27 minutes ago, Jennifer Chen said:

Roxas was also TOO Shy to Confess his Love for Naminé at the Ending of KH3 When They were on Destiny Islands, He didn't EVEN Have the Courage to Approach Her.

That's a lot of speculation going on there presented as facts.