Is the KH Fanbase Really Worse Than The Sonic Fanbase?

[Shulk 8,623]

I like KH2, but I also recognize it has its faults.

Don't get me wrong, I love KHII. I'm just also capable of seeing its flaws. I'm not trying to say you're one of those people who gets super defensive about it, either. I know you're not the type to praise it for being perfection.

[Dracozombie 4,554]

Pretty much every large fanbase is fun and atrocious in its own ways. I haven't been part of the Sonic fandom for a looooooong time, and even then it was mainly fanfiction, and during a time when the focus was on SA1, 2, and Heroes. What made me quit, personally, was the amount of awful awful fan characters. Sure, every fanbase has them, but Sonic is legendary for it.

 

When I moved onto other fandoms, I haven't really looked back. I only have second-hand accounts at how much the modern Sonic fanbase sucks. I don't think the KH fandom is as bad as Sonic's, but KH has the advantage of an overarching plot that compels people to keep following the series. Sonic games tend to be self-contained works that focus on gameplay rather than story. With games like KH or Final Fantasy, at least you can say you liked the story but disliked the mechanics, or vice versa. Not so with Sonic. There's nothing else for it, so if the gameplay sucks, the game sucks, period, and fans will complain. And I guess these days the gameplay isn't delivering.

 

I can't give my own opinion without parroting other opinions from sources like Game Grumps, so the most I can say is that the fanbase just plain doesn't think the games are good. What can you expect from a fanbase with poor games that does nothing but whine and moan? With their abysmal expectations for the next game coming out (and from my observations, it doesn't seem like the franchise is doing much to prove their expectations wrong), it makes me wonder why the fans stick around at all.

[hatok 6,413]

As a KH Fanboy, I can admit it is more annoying to be KH Fanboy than it is to be a Sonic Fanboy. The rest of the world doesn't understand how deep and epic KH is, so they tend to make fun of it, while Sonic is more of a simple, not sentimental game, so it is more praised.

Sonic fanboy here, Sonic's story is very under appreciated

[Rahin The Gamer 25]

Well as a fan of both series i can't really say they can be compared.

The Kingdom Hearts fanbase to me is split in two groups:

- Those who don't mind the side games (BBS, 358/2 Days, Re:Coded, 3D and COM).

- And those who whine for KH3. Don't get me wrong i understand it's been a LONG time, but it's like all they do is whine X game is not KH3.

But generally it's the more friendly out of the two.

 

The Sonic fanbase however is spilt in many different ways, the main being:

- Classic Fans

- Adventure Fans

- Modern Fans

and now:

- Boom Fans

 

There are probaly more divides in the fanbase too, and that is what makes it the aggressive out of the two especially after games like Sonic 06 and now Sonic Boom. The basic fustration of the Sonic fanbase is that every few games the formula is changed, when it isn't needed. That leads to more splits and more arguing, nitpicking and agression. So you really can't blame us too much for how 'bad' we may be.

[Weedanort 8,786]

Well as a fan of both series i can't really say they can be compared.

The Kingdom Hearts fanbase to me is split in two groups:

- Those who don't mind the side games (BBS, 358/2 Days, Re:Coded, 3D and COM).

- And those who whine for KH3. Don't get me wrong i understand it's been a LONG time, but it's like all they do is whine X game is not KH3.

But generally it's the more friendly out of the two.

 

The Sonic fanbase however is spilt in many different ways, the main being:

- Classic Fans

- Adventure Fans

- Modern Fans

and now:

- Boom Fans

 

There are probaly more divides in the fanbase too, and that is what makes it the aggressive out of the two especially after games like Sonic 06 and now Sonic Boom. The basic fustration of the Sonic fanbase is that every few games the formula is changed, when it isn't needed. That leads to more splits and more arguing, nitpicking and agression. So you really can't blame us too much for how 'bad' we may be.

 

Don't worry Sonic 06, now you finnaly have a buddy after all this time to get picked on