What if, in KHIII....

[Col.Random 3,683]

...Aqua dies?
I mean let's think about it.
+Nomura is a troll
+He's REALLY stressing on the "KH3 will be full of surprises" part (I think)
+The ending of BBS (blank points) shows a part where Ven and Terra are back in the Land of Departure, but there's no Aqua O_O

Okay this is more of just a simple question, rather than factual, so what I'm really asking is how you guys would react to it
Wow, I'm asking one seriously stupid question. Maybe i should go to bed ;-;

Edited June 19, 2013 by Col.Random

[Caity 3,946]

I assumed this too, well at least one of TAV would die and it wouldn't be expected held captive since BBS Terra since that would be expected.  

[EternalReckoning 1,135]

I dont think they will ever be physically back in LoD, it was probably something that happened in aqua's head. I would be surprised if aqua died but surprisingly there is quite a bit of speculation about it in the fan base atm. Its hard to know what nomura will do with her at this point but there is no evidence to suggest her death.

 

i liked your idea though it was more innovative than many i have read recently

[The_eternal_nothing 586]

lol impossible no one actually dies in kh

[Roxan nudge 16]

Terra is consumed by darkness . Aqua is stuck in eternal darkness because she was pulling a Derpy Hooves and tried to save Terra. Ventus' heart went to sleep and bonded into Sora's. Most likely Ventus' heart will wake up.Sora will somehow get Aqua out of eternal darkness and Terra we'll see about that. Anyhow people don't die in Kingdom Hearts. They get consumed by darkness or lose their heart. They have a afterlife. Which are nobodies. You can they are "dead" but aren't really.

[Daniel Black 1,981]

Death doesn´t exist (Yet) in  KH storyline... oh wait Ienzo´s parents... T_T

[Connected 978]

It sound really bad but I hope so... Story where only good wins and evil lose start to get boring. I want som emotion in the game!

And Aqua is real good person to die. the person who gave everything up to help her friends. and even give her life to let their friends live.

[VanitasTheBest 196]

I really think, if they're able to get Terra back somehow, he's going to die. He's kinda the reason that Xehanort could go on with his evil Plans and it'll be like the compensation for what he did. I could imagine something like that to happen, but Aqua... nah.

[Rob 5,571]

If the fans can revive Axel, they can surely revive Aqua.

[Robbie the Wise 5,050]

Why does someone have to die for the game to be good? I fail to understand this concept

[HarLea Quinn 26,501]

Why does someone have to die for the game to be good? I fail to understand this concept

 

Couldn't agree more !

[Reyn 1,755]

I doubt it. This isn't Final Fantasy where people actually die for real, this is Kingdom Hearts, where no one truly dies. Even though Eraqus should've been the first person to actually die, since he didn't lose his heart or come back or anything, but instead his heart is with Terra now, somehow. I doubt if anyone dies, they won't stay dead. They'll come back.

[HarLea Quinn 26,501]

I doubt it. This isn't Final Fantasy where people actually die for real, this is Kingdom Hearts, where no one truly dies. Even though Eraqus should've been the first person to actually die, since he didn't lose his heart or come back or anything, but instead his heart is with Terra now, somehow. I doubt if anyone dies, they won't stay dead. They'll come back.

 

Repliku says hi.

[DarknessOrLight 32]

Good idea. But I think we will see a death from one of the good guys in KH3. And for everybody saying death doesn't exist, how the heck is the Xehenort Saga gonna end? Xehanort needs to die...

[Reyn 1,755]

Repliku says hi.

 

Thats different, Repliku wasn't real to begin with, he was fake and never had a real heart. It seems like anyone who has a heart comes back eventually.

 

Good idea. But I think we will see a death from one of the good guys in KH3. And for everybody saying death doesn't exist, how the heck is the Xehenort Saga gonna end? Xehanort needs to die...

Good point, how is Xehanort going to be defeated, we will see.

[HarLea Quinn 26,501]

Thats different, Repliku wasn't real to begin with, he was fake and never had a real heart. It seems like anyone who has a heart comes back eventually.

 

Good point, how is Xehanort going to be defeated, we will see.

 

Repliku still counts .He had a heart whether it was made for him or he grew his own eventually too.Still counts. If you can count xion as a real person repliku counts too.She grew a heart as a replica so why couldn't repliku ?

[Reyn 1,755]

Repliku still counts .He had a heart whether it was made for him or he grew his own eventually too.Still counts. If you can count xion as a real person repliku counts too.She grew a heart as a replica so why couldn't repliku ?

Well, for Repliku, its not like he was a nobody or heartless of someone who was real. He was just that, a replica. The same rules don't apply. He's not a genuine, true human being, nor is he a heartless or Nobody, he's a clone, he's artificial, HE'S A FAKE. It does not count.

 

And Xion was just a replica too, but an incomplete one, while Repliku was a complete Replica. Xion absorbed the memories of Sora that Roxas had, and Roxas had a heart, so just being around him could've made Xion feel like she had a heart too. That's what happened with Axel. It was never said that she grew a heart, because she wasn't a real nobody. Just another replica. She just absorbed the memories that a NOBODY HAD. And those memories just happened to be of someone who HAD A HEART. So that along with being near Roxas could've made her feel like she had a heart, but that doesn't mean she ever gained one. Since she was a replica, she's the same as Repliku as in she is not a true human being, or a heartless or nobody.

[HarLea Quinn 26,501]

Well, for Repliku, its not like he was a nobody or heartless of someone who was real. He was just that, a replica. The same rules don't apply. He's not a genuine, true human being, nor is he a heartless or Nobody, he's a clone, he's artificial, HE'S A FAKE. It does not count.

 

And Xion was just a replica too, but an incomplete one, while Repliku was a complete Replica. Xion absorbed the memories of Sora that Roxas had, and Roxas had a heart, so just being around him could've made Xion feel like she had a heart too. That's what happened with Axel. It was never said that she grew a heart, because she wasn't a real nobody. Just another replica. She just absorbed the memories that a NOBODY HAD. And those memories just happened to be of someone who HAD A HEART. So that along with being near Roxas could've made her feel like she had a heart, but that doesn't mean she ever gained one. Since she was a replica, she's the same as Repliku as in she is not a true human being, or a heartless or nobody.

 

1.who says the same rule doesn't apply ?. He was a breathing ,living being that died .It sure as hell counts

2.Xion was actually considered the better version of a replica and was too successful and started to form her own being and grow her own heart . This is why she felt like she had one and this was confirmed in DDD itself by Xemnas " even a heartless puppet' can grow a heart  and Ansem the wise in the end of DDD. They call her a freakin' puppet all through Days. Axel was also stated to grow his own heart bc he was around sora and roxas who had hearts and helped him nurture his to grow also confirmed by xemnas who admitted that he lied to the org members who could actually grow hearts and did not know it. Did you miss the entire ending with Ansem the wise too? Holy shit.

[DarknessOrLight 32]

Well, for Repliku, its not like he was a nobody or heartless of someone who was real. He was just that, a replica. The same rules don't apply. He's not a genuine, true human being, nor is he a heartless or Nobody, he's a clone, he's artificial, HE'S A FAKE. It does not count.

 

And Xion was just a replica too, but an incomplete one, while Repliku was a complete Replica. Xion absorbed the memories of Sora that Roxas had, and Roxas had a heart, so just being around him could've made Xion feel like she had a heart too. That's what happened with Axel. It was never said that she grew a heart, because she wasn't a real nobody. Just another replica. She just absorbed the memories that a NOBODY HAD. And those memories just happened to be of someone who HAD A HEART. So that along with being near Roxas could've made her feel like she had a heart, but that doesn't mean she ever gained one. Since she was a replica, she's the same as Repliku as in she is not a true human being, or a heartless or nobody.

Xion and Repliku go by the same rules. It does count for Repliku as much as it does for Xion. 

[Reyn 1,755]

1.who says the same rule doesn't apply ?. He was a breathing ,living being that died .It sure as hell counts

2.Xion was actually considered the better version of a replica and was too successful and started to form her own being and grow her own heart . This is why she felt like she had one and this was confirmed in DDD itself by Xemnas " even a heartless puppet' can grow a heart  and Ansem the wise in the end of DDD. They call her a freakin' puppet all through Days. Axel was also stated to grow his own heart bc he was around sora and roxas who had hearts and helped him nurture his to grow also confirmed by xemnas who admitted that he lied to the org members who could actually grow hearts and did not know it. Did you miss the entire ending with Ansem the wise too? Holy shit.

1. Well so far, it would seem people who were real, came back in some sort of way. Xemnas and Ansem SOD came back as Master Xehanort for an example. Anyone who dies that is real, has come back as themselves, or in some other form. But Repliku hasn't come back because he isn't real. I don't think it counts. As for Xion, she can still come back, as the ending for DDD implies that she and Roxas could still be saved, since Ansem TW gave Riku the data to accomplish that. But Xion could come back, since she was absorbed by Roxas who was real and not a replica of someone else.

2. Ok fine, i was wrong on that part. I need to get my facts straight on that.

Xion and Repliku go by the same rules. It does count for Repliku as much as it does for Xion. 

Well in Xion's case, she was absorbed by someone who was real(Roxas) and as implied in the ending of DDD, could be brought back along with Roxas with the data the ATW gave Riku. Xion's case was special, Repliku's wasn't.

[HarLea Quinn 26,501]

1. Well so far, it would seem people who were real, came back in some sort of way. Xemnas and Ansem SOD came back as Master Xehanort for an example. Anyone who dies that is real, has come back as themselves, or in some other form. But Repliku hasn't come back because he isn't real. I don't think it counts. As for Xion, she can still come back, as the ending for DDD implies that she and Roxas could still be saved, since Ansem TW gave Riku the data to accomplish that. But Xion could come back, since she was absorbed by Roxas who was real and not a replica of someone else.

2. Ok fine, i was wrong on that part. I need to get my facts straight on that.

Well in Xion's case, she was absorbed by someone who was real(Roxas) and as implied in the ending of DDD, could be brought back along with Roxas with the data the ATW gave Riku. Xion's case was special, Repliku's wasn't.

 

Repliku was a replica of RIKU - A real person so using your logic you are contradicting yourself .He also grew his own heart or was capable of so that makes him no different than Xion .He died and counts like any other person .The only difference was he wasn't able to 'live' in Sora like Xion had the chance to.He was even made by the same circumstances and same 'people'.

[Reyn 1,755]

Repliku was a replica of RIKU - A real person so using your logic you are contradicting yourself .He also grew his own heart or was capable of so that makes him no different than Xion .He died and counts like any other person .The only difference was he wasn't able to 'live' in Sora like Xion had the chance to.He was even made by the same circumstances and same 'people'.

Ok fine, you've convinced me. One person has died in the whole KH series and hasn't come back. But its only one person. Everyone else has come back. I think that if any of the other good characters die, they'll come back sooner or later.

[HarLea Quinn 26,501]

Ok fine, you've convinced me. One person has died in the whole KH series and hasn't come back. But its only one person. Everyone else has come back. I think that if any of the other good characters die, they'll come back sooner or later.

I'm not saying that people don't tend to come back but i had to point out there are exceptions.I'm not even going to go into how many disney characters died like mufasa and lady tremaine and the step-sisters, ursula, and frollo just to name a few .It's quite possible that since it's the end of the xehanort saga and nomura wants to tie everything 'xehanort' up we might just see him die. Ya never know.

[Reyn 1,755]

I'm not saying that people don't tend to come back but i had to point out there are exceptions.I'm not even going to go into how many disney characters died like mufasa and lady tremaine and the step-sisters, ursula, and frollo just to name a few .It's quite possible that since it's the end of the xehanort saga and nomura wants to tie everything 'xehanort' up we might just see him die. Ya never know.

True, there are exceptions. But, we're mainly just talking about the KH specific characters, not the disney ones, even if they are exceptions, since they aren't really worth mentioning considering how their only there to give you something to do in each of the worlds, and barely contribute to the plot after the first game. But yes, they are exceptions. But so far, the only KH specific character exception is Repliku.

[HarLea Quinn 26,501]

True, there are exceptions. But, we're mainly just talking about the KH specific characters, not the disney ones, even if they are exceptions, since they aren't really worth mentioning considering how their only there to give you something to do in each of the worlds, and barely contribute to the plot after the first game. But yes, they are exceptions. But so far, the only KH specific character exception is Repliku.

 

Well Eraqus might be too depending on what Nomura decides to do with him . He technically 'died", but also has hidden his heart in Terra's and it's possible to bring him back I suppose especially considering the hidden data from Ansem the Wise. It just depends on what Nomura decides to do with his character in the long haul. We know he will have some role /effect in KH3 though. Exactly what is debateable.