Power Struggle

[naught2 0]

Sora has 3 heats inside of him. (Sora, Roxas, Xion) Xion returned at the end of Days and Roxas at the beginning of KH2. [Ven is not there because his heart was released in KH1] I was thinking what if Sora went beserk and had a Power Struggle in his heart between the 3 of them to see who would control Sora's body.

 

What do you think? Who would you want to win?

[Tom 437]

Wow I think I am going to be a douchebag about this but you got two things wrong

 

1) Xion doesn't have a heart. Well a fake one that is. It's still wouldn't do much as she's bascially just memories now when she went back to Sora.

2) Ven's heart never released. Ven's heart is apart of Sora's heart. Otherwise, when Sora stabbed himself to return Kairi's heart back to her body, we would of seen three. But we saw two float out: Sora's and Kairi's

 

But I would like to see Roxas take over. One badass. But Xion would be great too

[Kishira 2,854]

Sora!!!!!!!! He's proven over and over agian he's stronger than one might think. Plus, I just adore Sora. <3

[naught2 0]

Wow I think I am going to be a douchebag about this but you got two things wrong

 

1) Xion doesn't have a heart. Well a fake one that is. It's still wouldn't do much as she's bascially just memories now when she went back to Sora.

2) Ven's heart never released. Ven's heart is apart of Sora's heart. Otherwise, when Sora stabbed himself to return Kairi's heart back to her body, we would of seen three. But we saw two float out: Sora's and Kairi's

 

But I would like to see Roxas take over. One badass. But Xion would be great too

 

Wow I think I am going to be a douchebag about this but you got two things wrong

 

1) Xion may have a heart because although she is a "doll" with Sora's leaked memories, it is never stated that she is a nobody. Plus the Riku "doll" in CoM may not have had a heart, but it made its own decisions at the end of the game and acted as if it did. So it is possible to gain a heart if you don't start out with one.

2) Go back and look again!!!! ONLY 1 HEART COMES OUT OF SORA. Kairi's heart is released and floats back into her while Sora falls and disappears. NO OTHER HEARTS ARE SEEN COMING OUT OF SORA. Just because you don't see the hearts doesn't mean they are not there.

[KeyOfVentus 90]

Also Roxas doesn't have a heart, he's a nobody.

[Tom 437]

 

Wow I think I am going to be a douchebag about this but you got two things wrong

 

1) Xion doesn't have a heart. Well a fake one that is. It's still wouldn't do much as she's bascially just memories now when she went back to Sora.

2) Ven's heart never released. Ven's heart is apart of Sora's heart. Otherwise, when Sora stabbed himself to return Kairi's heart back to her body, we would of seen three. But we saw two float out: Sora's and Kairi's

 

But I would like to see Roxas take over. One badass. But Xion would be great too

 

Wow I think I am going to be a douchebag about this but you got two things wrong

 

1) Xion may have a heart because although she is a "doll" with Sora's leaked memories, it is never stated that she is a nobody. Plus the Riku "doll" in CoM may not have had a heart, but it made its own decisions at the end of the game and acted as if it did. So it is possible to gain a heart if you don't start out with one.

2) Go back and look again!!!! ONLY 1 HEART COMES OUT OF SORA. Kairi's heart is released and floats back into her while Sora falls and disappears. NO OTHER HEARTS ARE SEEN COMING OUT OF SORA. Just because you don't see the hearts doesn't mean they are not there.

 

1) She didn't, alright. There's no reasoning that she got a heart. She's a doll, a puppet. Use logic and not fanfiction

 

2) I did check, but just because 1 heart came out, doesn't mean Sora's didn't either. Because if Sora's heart didn't, then how are we supposed to explain how Roxas was created? Oh so Sora mysteriously disappears and then OMG Roxas appears. Makes perfect sense. That's basically what you said.

 

Don't try to correct me with info you can't back up.

[RoxSox 3,593]

I agree with Deathskull here...

Naught, your theory is 'naught' right..

I've been waiting to unleash that

[kingdom24 0]

Wow I think I am going to be a douchebag about this but you got two things wrong

 

1) Xion doesn't have a heart. Well a fake one that is. It's still wouldn't do much as she's bascially just memories now when she went back to Sora.

2) Ven's heart never released. Ven's heart is apart of Sora's heart. Otherwise, when Sora stabbed himself to return Kairi's heart back to her body, we would of seen three. But we saw two float out: Sora's and Kairi's

 

But I would like to see Roxas take over. One badass. But Xion would be great too

 

they did not know about ven them self on the first kh the just thought about him thats y only 2 hearts where released.

[RoxSox 3,593]

Um, what? use of puncuation would be great

[angie-la 0]

If there was actually 3 hearts in Sora, I guess Roxas would win. I'm biased because I like Roxas better than Sora.

[eentje 0]

Nobody would win, but I guess Sora's heart would implode if they were fighting.

[angie-la 0]

^...

that makes sense.

[RoxAs Is Wise 7]

agree with eentje, though I think they can't even start fighting, they don't have consciousness inside sora, do they?

[Disoriented 1]

Sora has 3 heats inside of him. (Sora, Roxas, Xion) Xion returned at the end of Days and Roxas at the beginning of KH2. [Ven is not there because his heart was released in KH1] I was thinking what if Sora went beserk and had a Power Struggle in his heart between the 3 of them to see who would control Sora's body.

 

What do you think? Who would you want to win?

 

[align=center]Let's take this apart piece by piece, shall we?

 

"Sora has 3 hearts inside of him."

 

When, exactly? Well, in Kingdom Hearts he has three hearts, his own, Ventus's, and Kairi's. Upon his kamikaze act, he releases Kairi's heart ( along with releasing the six other Princess's hearts heart with the destruction of the Keyblade of People's Hearts ), and in some cheap Matrix rip off, Sora himself loses his heart in a similar manner to that of Ventus and Vanitas ( with the whole..."burst into a million pieces" type of..heart losing...moving on. ) It is speculated whether or not Sora's heart released Ventus's heart from inside it and set Ventus's heart free...either that, or Ventus's heart remains fused with Sora's. Kairi then uses her light to restore Sora's heartless to human form, making Sora "incomplete" until the late beginning of Kingdom Hearts 2.

 

So now Sora only has ONE heart, which would be his own. And if Ventus's heart didn't leave Sora's heart, then Sora has TWO hearts. Not three. And so Sora carries that number of hearts through the story up to now.

 

"(Sora, Roxas, Xion)"

Now I assume you are referring to the hearts inside Sora? Just a note, in correct grammar, ( you place the parenthesis within the sentence that you intend it and then add the period at the end ).

Sora's heart? Check.

Roxas's heart? Wait...what heart? Roxas is a Nobody, and the definition of a Nobody requires Roxas to NOT have a heart. True, Roxas is a special Nobody who can freely exhibit emotions--as much as that may confuse him--but that is not because he has a heart, but because Sora is still "alive" and has his heart, and Roxas--being Sora's Nobody--can feel Sora's heart, even if it is not inside him. Why? Because Sora and Roxas are connected by one heart, that is why.

Xion's heart? It's debatable whether or not she has a heart. Repliku is like Xion and he had a heart, so people would assume Xion had a heart as well. But Xion had no memories of a heart, so the emotions she can exhibit make little to no sense to her and is one trigger to her insanity ( a heart IS a heavy burden, I have heard ). Regardless, you say that Xion returns to Sora. Incorrect. Sora's leaked memories return to Sora, as well as Xion's memories. But Xion herself? No, the process of returning those memories results in her death. Any heart she could have possessed is rendered useless.

 

"Xion returned at the end of Days and Roxas at the beginning of KH2."

 

I've already explained Xion's "return to Sora," which, I repeat, is just all the memories returning to him. Roxas, we can come to a mutual agreement that Roxas returns to Sora at the beginning of Kingdom Hearts 2, thus making Sora "whole" again. Great, Sora's Heartless and Nobody have joined together and Sora's memories are all back in working order ( plus Xion's memories, which are locked away inside Sora's heart ). Roxas only had his power to give, which he did once he joined with Sora. There was no heart transfer or anything involved since Roxas and Sora both share the same heart, and that heart was inside Sora the entire time.

 

"[Ven is not there because his heart was released in KH1]"

Do you have any proof of that? No, you don't. Nothing has been confirmed yet by the creators whether or not Ventus's heart was released from Sora's when Sora lost his heart. I'm guessing Ventus's heart is still fused with Sora's heart, and the only way to separate them is to repeat history. Yes, I'm referring to the process of Vanitas's birth, where Master Xehanort took Ventus's heart and split it into two. Again, I'm GUESSING that, but I'm not saying anything for sure.

 

"I was thinking what if Sora went beserk"

Why would Sora suddenly go berserk when he's had no history of going berserk in the past ( the ability "MP Rage" does not count )? And what would cause him to go berserk? I would bet money that it would take something huge to send SORA into a BERSERK state.

 

"and had a Power Struggle in his heart between the 3 of them to see who would control Sora's body. "

That'd be a pathetic battle, no offense. Roxas and Sora already had a "Power Struggle" in Kingdom Hearts 2 ( in The World That Never Was at Memory's Skyscraper ) and Roxas lost, returning peacefully to Sora again. Roxas has already accepted the fact that he is just a part of Sora and nothing more, as depressing as that sounds. I personally find it unlikely for Roxas to attack Sora again just to "gain control of his body."

Actually, I really don't think it works that way anyway ( if you want to use the "Vanitas takes over Ventus's body!" excuse, I'm afraid you can't. Vanitas takes over and control of Ventus's body because his heart is stronger, just like Master Xehanort takes over and controls Terra's body because Xehanort's heart is stronger, and in Kingdom Hearts, "Ansem" takes over Riku's body because he is a powerful HEARTLESS, and one would assume Heartless have hearts as the release hearts upon destruction ( well, Emblem Heartless like "Ansem" do, anyway ). Following this pattern of stronger hearts winning over the bodies, Roxas would have a rather difficult time taking over Sora's body when Roxas and Sora share the same heart ).

The only connection that Sora has to Xion is her memories inside his heart...and Roxas's forgotten friendship with her. I'm not sure if you caught this in Days, but Xion died. So having Xion randomly pop up to challenge Sora inside his Awakening is highly unlikely.

 

"What do you think?"

I think I've told you what I think.

 

"Who would you want to win?"

Sora automatically wins by default. There was no challenge or "Power Struggle" to begin with.[/align]