Organization XIII vs. Disney Villain Bloc

[Dave 5,715]

Basic sort of question: which did you find to be the more compelling antagonists of Kingdom Hearts: Organization XIII or the Disney Villain Bloc of KH1?

 

The Disney Villains have a definate edge in screen presence and personality as a whole, with each member bringing something to liven up the group: Hades' fast talking, Ursula's manipulativeness, Oogie's insane humor, Malificient's silky smooth evil, Captain Hook's comedic bungling, Jafar's aloof aristocratic behavior. While the Organization is a fun batch of people, I think there are a few too many "stoic and stone faced/ quietly plotting" members to really outshine the Disney cast, if it came down to who would provide better conversation. However, the Organization has the benefit of a more coherent story and aim: they have a definate plan in KHII, and said plan is constantly developed upon through the efforts of each member's appearance in the game. As such, their overall impression was more lasting and had greater significance. With KH1, the only one who seems to know the whole plan is Malificient, and the other villains are almost just cameos, their contributions to the grand plot not as developed in greater detail as they might have been.

 

Discuss.

[Arya Stark 1,337]

Sorry but what kind of question is this? Organization XIII is obviously the better antagonists. I coudn't tell you why but they just are.

[Nick Sideris 1,551]

Sorry but what kind of question is this? Organization XIII is obviously the better antagonists. I coudn't tell you why but they just are.

 

I totally agree...

[Grimmjow 839]

I like both but since I LOVE the Disney villains in KH I and you people don't give enough credit to them my vote goes to them.

[Sora'sMum 352]

Although I like both parties, my vote has got to go to the Organisation, mostly because they're completely bad ass. And they get extra points just because of Xemnas' incredibly awesome voice. Plus, they've all got awesome hairdos!

[Pikappa93 9]

Organization XIII. Absolutely.

[lizzie1238 538]

Definitely Organization XIII.

[HarLea Quinn 26,501]

The Organization x 1000000000

[VoidXName 346]

I think if this was Maleficent vs. Orginazation XIII, I would have a harder time deciding. I really like Maleficent's role in all of the games, but I've gotta go with the Orginazation on this one.

[MAtgS 70]

How the **** are the Disney villains losing this poll?!

 

An element, a weapon & a number does not equate compelling characterazation. Disney villains are scene stealing beacons of charisma & style, Org13 ramble a bunch of incoherent dialog in a vain attempt to sound deeper than they actually are. Some of them had such little screen time in KH2 If Nomura had any sense he wouldn't have gone so overboard with bland new characters & let the DVs remain the prime threat.

[barry2255 48]

Orginzation XIII FTW!

[Isamu Kuno 2,512]

The Disney Villains didn't even have a group name and after KH they never worked together again. I mean c'mon Oogie pretty much said "F you" to Maleficent and she never even tried to contact the others. The Disney villains are definitely more entertaining both one on one and as a whole but the Organization is just more, well, organised. So for entertainment purposes the Disney Villains win but Organization XIII is a bigger threat. So it depends on what you mean by "better".

 

Btw. I want Mother Gothel and Dr. Facileir to be in Kingdom Hearts 3. They're both so funny.

Edited October 2, 2012 by Sora_Kuno

[Gambler'sApprentice 131]

The Orgnization has more dynamic characters, with a goal you can at least sympathize with, even if you don't think mass producing Heartless is a good thing, it's hardly evil to want your heart back.