Who do you think Demyx is?

[Vulpes XIII 38]

Although I don’t have any theories of my own, I have read a few different theories about who Demyx might be and i was wondering if anyone has any theories or if anyone thinks any of these theories could be possible? My thoughts on the theories I’ve seen are: 

Demyx is from Quadratum - This is the one that is most likely to happen in my opinion as considering members 9-12 all have the ancient Keyblade legacy within them and as Lauriam and Elrena are from Daybreak Town and Luxord is from Quadratum it just seems that he most likely going to be from Quadratum as well.

Demyx is the player from Union X - This is unlikely, however I do find it a very interesting theory in my opinion and I wouldn’t mind if it was true. As the default male character does kind of look like a younger Demyx in some ways and the player character seems like all they want to do is make friends wherever they go and in the KH3 character files Demyx says

” why am I in the Organization well I mean there lots of reasons but - oh right I wanted friends right”

Although the Player could fight and fought when they needed to they still seemed like they would rather not have to resort to conflict and would rather talk things out if they could and on the other hand we have Demyx who can fight but hates it and avoids it whenever he can as he doesn’t like work and would rather sit playing his sitar all day. Although if Demyx was in the Keyblade war back then, maybe it’s possible that although he can’t remember his past including the Keyblade war perhaps it somehow subconsciously influenced his Nobody personality and if that was the case it would make this part of Demyx character file interesting 

“ I hate fighting and jamming out is way more fun, sad stuff, painful stuff why would I want to do anything like that? I guess there’s the stuff you got to do to survive but if I can I’d much rather live a life on easy street”. Also it makes this line from KH2 quite interesting as well 

“ I’m extremely imposing when I want to be which is admittedly almost never” again this theory is unlikely to happen but I still find it interesting.

Demyx is one of the upperclassman that went missing in Dark Road - I don’t think this would be the case as if he existed around this time period I don’t think this would count as having a ancient Keyblade legacy as young Xehanort and young Eraqus were around then too.

Finally Demyx is the MoM - I don’t like this theory, I want the MoM to be his own character not someone else we have had enough of that happen in the series already. Although I’ll admit that even though I don’t like this theory and don’t want this to happen, I would rather Demyx be the MoM instead of Sora, if the MoM has to be a character that already exists.

Anyway what does everyone else think of these theories do you want any of these to be true? Or do you have any other theories that you think could happen? I’m curious what everyone else thinks 

 

[Double OKP 171]

Hmm...Well, reincarnation is something that hasn't been introduced in the series so far, and it is entirely possible that it will never. I think Demyx being the reincarnate of the MoM would be 100% likely to happen if reincarnation was a thing. I'm not the biggest fan of it but it would definitely be interesting(and that 'I'm extremely imposing when I want to be which is admittedly almost never' quote kinda sounds like the MoM 'cause he's never been seen as imposing). And honestly, I really hate that idea of Sora being the MoM. I also do not like the idea of Demyx being [Player]. About [Player], he has two defaults; one for the mobile app, which I believe is what you're referencing, and the one from XBC, the [Player] in this having dark aqua-ish hair. Demyx being one of the upperclassmen is not going to happen, I'm very certain. I don't like the idea either and it just doesn't make sense time-wise. Demyx being from Quadratum is the one I find most likely

[Dagesh Lene 366]

I think that, if Demyx is going to be revealed to be anyone, it will be the Master of Masters. It would be nice if MoM was his own character, but I think that it is extremely unlikely. Why put someone in a black coat if they aren't going to have a dramatic reveal when the hood comes off? And the only way for it to be a dramatic reveal is if it's a character we already know. I really hate the idea of MoM being Sora. I hope that he isn't him. Plus, I believe that Nomura has said in the past that Sora will always be the hero, although he could always change his mind. But assuming that Sora will always be the hero, the only other person I could see being MoM is Demyx, unless he is a character we haven't been introduced to yet. I suppose there is a chance that MoM is the embodiment of Light, kind of like how we have now been introduced to the embodiment of Darkness, but I don't think that is as likely.

Edited January 8, 2021 by Dagesh Lene

[ocean's rage 774]

i think hes demyx

[SweetYetSalty 330]

Who is Demyx? I dunno. There was a time I would have liked to just seen him as some random sitar player that got turned into a Nobody, but I suppose that's too easy. I don't like the idea of him being the Master of Masters or time displaced, but the latter seems likely. I'm hoping he's like Luxord and from Quadratum. That seems interesting enough.

[Vulpes XIII 38]

20 hours ago, Double OKP said:

Hmm...Well, reincarnation is something that hasn't been introduced in the series so far, and it is entirely possible that it will never. I think Demyx being the reincarnate of the MoM would be 100% likely to happen if reincarnation was a thing. I'm not the biggest fan of it but it would definitely be interesting(and that 'I'm extremely imposing when I want to be which is admittedly almost never' quote kinda sounds like the MoM 'cause he's never been seen as imposing). And honestly, I really hate that idea of Sora being the MoM. I also do not like the idea of Demyx being [Player]. About [Player], he has two defaults; one for the mobile app, which I believe is what you're referencing, and the one from XBC, the [Player] in this having dark aqua-ish hair. Demyx being one of the upperclassmen is not going to happen, I'm very certain. I don't like the idea either and it just doesn't make sense time-wise. Demyx being from Quadratum is the one I find most likely

I never thought about reincarnation as a plot point before but I don’t think I would want to see it happen as I mentioned in my previous post I think we have enough of this character is actually another character situation going on in the series I think reincarnation would just make things worse. The Player from the mobile app was definitely the one I was referencing, I actually completely forgot about the Player in XBC not sure how I managed to forget that lol  

9 hours ago, SweetYetSalty said:

Who is Demyx? I dunno. There was a time I would have liked to just seen him as some random sitar player that got turned into a Nobody, but I suppose that's too easy. I don't like the idea of him being the Master of Masters or time displaced, but the latter seems likely. I'm hoping he's like Luxord and from Quadratum. That seems interesting enough.

Before KH3 came out I was also wanting Demyx to be some random person who just somehow managed to get caught up in this mess and that honestly who I thought he would be especially after hearing we could learn water magic as I thought he would of been the one to teach us as I actually imagined we would end up with a situation that went something like this (well maybe not exactly like this)

Sora : Hey I know you 

Demyx: sees Sora standing there and starts freaking out thinking Sora’s going to fight him again 

Sora: unable to get a word in or just standing there confused 

Demyx then teaches him water magic to get him to not fight him and Sora says something about how he wasn’t actually going to fight him in the first place followed by Demyx surprised reaction and then complaining how he had just done work when it turned out there was no reason to do any work in the first place.

As much as i would of liked something silly like that to happen for a laugh, I’m glad it didn’t because it means that Demyx has a interesting role in the series instead of being some random guy who is just there for one scene and doesn’t ever appear again.

 

Edited January 9, 2021 by Vulpes XIII

[Allwil13 754]

I actually do like the idea of Demyx being from Quadratum, and since he's the member immediately before Luxord who has basically been unofficially confirmed as being from Quadratum, I definitely think it's possible. I have heard the theories that Demyx is the MoM, but I'm hoping that this isn't the case. HOnestly though, one of my favourite things about the KH series is how good it is at subverting my expectations. Usually I'm really good at predicting stories and events, but there have only been a handful of instances with the KH series wherein my theories were actually correct. So honestly, I'm not entirely confident in any of my Demyx theories yet.

[ocean's rage 774]

6 hours ago, Allwil13 said:

Luxord who has basically been unofficially confirmed as being from Quadratum

when?

[Allwil13 754]

3 hours ago, ocean's rage said:

when?

I guess even "unofficially confirmed" is premature, but in the ending of the Limit Cut, when YOzora wakes up in the car, the driver's voice is Luxord's voice. Could be a coincidence, but it seems deliberate. 

[ocean's rage 774]

2 hours ago, Allwil13 said:

I guess even "unofficially confirmed" is premature, but in the ending of the Limit Cut, when YOzora wakes up in the car, the driver's voice is Luxord's voice. Could be a coincidence, but it seems deliberate. 

in both japanese and engligh or just the one?

[Allwil13 754]

3 hours ago, ocean's rage said:

in both japanese and engligh or just the one?

In both. If it's not the same voices then it's a freakish coincidence.

[ocean's rage 774]

42 minutes ago, Allwil13 said:

In both. If it's not the same voices then it's a freakish coincidence.

defiantly feels like jumping the gun on that one

[Allwil13 754]

5 minutes ago, ocean's rage said:

defiantly feels like jumping the gun on that one

Maybe. Time will tell. Regardless I would like it if Demyx were from Quadratum. 

[ocean's rage 774]

2 hours ago, Allwil13 said:

Maybe. Time will tell. Regardless I would like it if Demyx were from Quadratum. 

certainly would be interesting