The General Plot-Hole thread.

[RoxSox 3,593]

Every series has them, KH is not an exception.

With so many new games coming up that are so deeply linked into the series, fan's are bound to notice some... well lets just call them inconsistancies...

 

Any valid plot hole you've unearthed will be added into this post for us to discuss, starting now.

[Amon 4,279]

Don't open if you haven't unlocked the final episode in BBS and don't want things spoiled

 

Who the heck is the mysterious figure?

 

[RoxSox 3,593]

That's not exactly a plot-hole, Fred.

[Keyblader 325]

im sorry i dont have the slightest clue what a plot-hole is

[RoxSox 3,593]

A plot hole is when one part of a series completely contradicts another.

 

I.E: Goofy told Sora in KH2 that Mickey banished Pete,

but it was actually Minnie

 

[Amon 4,279]

That's not exactly a plot-hole, Fred.

 

 

I always thought a plot hole is something in the story that was never explained

[RoxSox 3,593]

Nope. Thats "Mystery".

There's a difference...

[Keyblader 325]

oh ok, well lets see, um, here might be one that might work,

 

xemnas says in kh2 that roxas looks a lot like sora, but yet he probably looks the least like his nobody because

 

 

of ventus's heart inside him

 

 

[hawk222 152]

No, see, he's saying that Roxas looks a lot like Ventus, because Xemnas=Terra's body (Xehanort's heart?), who remembers what Ventus looks like. So he's not referring to Sora at all!

[TheNobodyPie 0]

I'm not sure if this needs a spoiler tag or not but it's seen in the BBS Trailers too so...I guess not?

But the biggest plot hole that I've noticed in Kingdom Hearts is:

BBS - Donald and Goofy are at Yen Sid's Tower.

KH2 - While in front of Yen Sid's Tower Donald yells: MASTER YEN SID LIVES HERE?!?!?

 

Really Donald?

[RoxSox 3,593]

I'm not sure if this needs a spoiler tag or not but it's seen in the BBS Trailers too so...I guess not?

But the biggest plot hole that I've noticed in Kingdom Hearts is:

BBS - Donald and Goofy are at Yen Sid's Tower.

KH2 - While in front of Yen Sid's Tower Donald yells: MASTER YEN SID LIVES HERE?!?!?

 

Really Donald?

 

I've always felt that that line was more of a misread one then a plothole.

The voice actor said it in a inquisitive tone, but if you think about, a slight change can make it into an exclamation:

"Master Yen Sid lives HERE?"

^ original.

replacement v

"Master Yen Sid lives here!"

[AwersomeOne 109]

 

No, see, he's saying that Roxas looks a lot like Ventus, because Xemnas=Terra's body (Xehanort's heart?), who remembers what Ventus looks like. So he's not referring to Sora at all!

 

 

 

its not xehanort in terras body dude, aqua freed terra and sent xehanort back to the darkness.

 

[Godot 513]

The ages of the scientists and their nobodies...

 

In BBS, Ienzo is around 12 years old, but, in CoM (which takes place 10 years later) Zexion is 17/18. lolwut

 

 

Not to mention

no one in Organization XIII finds it odd that a huge chunk of their memories is gone? (Since they can't remember Xion...what do they remember instead? .-.)

Though that may just be because I skimmed through the storyline too much and didn't catch where they explained it.

[TripleNipple 308]

I know it's been like Ten Years not that long,and i Know that people stop changing how they look at one age.(KH BBS SPOILER(Secret Ending Question)

Why didn't Aqua change at all?Not Even a streak of hair,her height,her voice,her clothes(lol)and she doesn't even have any wrinkles *GASP*

[Rae 1]

I know it's been like Ten Years not that long,and i Know that people stop changing how they look at one age.(KH BBS SPOILER(Secret Ending Question)

Why didn't Aqua change at all?Not Even a streak of hair,her height,her voice,her clothes(lol)and she doesn't even have any wrinkles *GASP*

 

 

I thought it was stated that in the world of darkness you don't age/grow hungry/thirst?

A plot hole I'd like explained is why

Both terra and Xehanort can use keyblades, but Xemnas can't. I've gone through all the possible reasons, and none of them make sense.

 

[Deadshot 666]

 

I know it's been like Ten Years not that long,and i Know that people stop changing how they look at one age.(KH BBS SPOILER(Secret Ending Question)

Why didn't Aqua change at all?Not Even a streak of hair,her height,her voice,her clothes(lol)and she doesn't even have any wrinkles *GASP*

 

 

I thought it was stated that in the world of darkness you don't age/grow hungry/thirst?

A plot hole I'd like explained is why

Both terra and Xehanort can use keyblades, but Xemnas can't. I've gone through all the possible reasons, and none of them make sense.

 

 

i know it makes no sense why can't xenmas used a keyblade but then there would be no point of eoxas in organization

[Rae 1]

 

 

I know it's been like Ten Years not that long,and i Know that people stop changing how they look at one age.(KH BBS SPOILER(Secret Ending Question)

Why didn't Aqua change at all?Not Even a streak of hair,her height,her voice,her clothes(lol)and she doesn't even have any wrinkles *GASP*

 

 

I thought it was stated that in the world of darkness you don't age/grow hungry/thirst?

A plot hole I'd like explained is why

Both terra and Xehanort can use keyblades, but Xemnas can't. I've gone through all the possible reasons, and none of them make sense.

 

 

i know it makes no sense why can't xenmas used a keyblade but then there would be no point of eoxas in organization

 

That's not a valid reason. That's the same as "They made it that way/Just because".

They need to have a reason that makes sense, and has to do with the actual game/plot.

[TheNobodyPie 0]

 

I'm not sure if this needs a spoiler tag or not but it's seen in the BBS Trailers too so...I guess not?

But the biggest plot hole that I've noticed in Kingdom Hearts is:

BBS - Donald and Goofy are at Yen Sid's Tower.

KH2 - While in front of Yen Sid's Tower Donald yells: MASTER YEN SID LIVES HERE?!?!?

 

Really Donald?

 

I've always felt that that line was more of a misread one then a plothole.

The voice actor said it in a inquisitive tone, but if you think about, a slight change can make it into an exclamation:

"Master Yen Sid lives HERE?"

^ original.

replacement v

"Master Yen Sid lives here!"

 

But the thing is the subtitles in the game read with a question mark and wouldn't that be the game script??

Oh well, I'll always see it as a fun plot hole though.

It's Donald.

[Deadshot 666]

 

 

 

I know it's been like Ten Years not that long,and i Know that people stop changing how they look at one age.(KH BBS SPOILER(Secret Ending Question)

Why didn't Aqua change at all?Not Even a streak of hair,her height,her voice,her clothes(lol)and she doesn't even have any wrinkles *GASP*

 

 

I thought it was stated that in the world of darkness you don't age/grow hungry/thirst?

A plot hole I'd like explained is why

Both terra and Xehanort can use keyblades, but Xemnas can't. I've gone through all the possible reasons, and none of them make sense.

 

 

i know it makes no sense why can't xenmas used a keyblade but then there would be no point of roxas in organization

 

That's not a valid reason. That's the same as "They made it that way/Just because".

They need to have a reason that makes sense, and has to do with the actual game/plot.

 

i never said this was valid reason i don't really anwser to it

[khven 0]

 

 

No, see, he's saying that Roxas looks a lot like Ventus, because Xemnas=Terra's body (Xehanort's heart?), who remembers what Ventus looks like. So he's not referring to Sora at all!

 

 

 

its not xehanort in terras body dude, aqua freed terra and sent xehanort back to the darkness.

 

 

that is way off. she sent him out of the drnkness by letting herself get trapped instead

[Ventus/Roxas 0]

actully terras key blade is at the kbgr the reson xemeness cant use the keyblad becaus mx and terra are still fighting inside

[TripleNipple 308]

 

 

I'm not sure if this needs a spoiler tag or not but it's seen in the BBS Trailers too so...I guess not?

But the biggest plot hole that I've noticed in Kingdom Hearts is:

BBS - Donald and Goofy are at Yen Sid's Tower.

KH2 - While in front of Yen Sid's Tower Donald yells: MASTER YEN SID LIVES HERE?!?!?

 

Really Donald?

 

I've always felt that that line was more of a misread one then a plothole.

The voice actor said it in a inquisitive tone, but if you think about, a slight change can make it into an exclamation:

"Master Yen Sid lives HERE?"

^ original.

replacement v

"Master Yen Sid lives here!"

 

But the thing is the subtitles in the game read with a question mark and wouldn't that be the game script??

Oh well, I'll always see it as a fun plot hole though.

It's Donald.

 

That's just how donald is.

[AJTREY 70]

I believe that is easily explained. Remember that in Kingdom Hearts Birth by Sleep Master Yen Sid's Tower is a separate world. However, in Kingdom Hearts II, Yen Sid's tower becomes a part of Twilight Town. Therefore that is different and could therefore make it a bit confusing for donald

[hatok 6,413]

So far I'm not seeing as much plot-holes as parts of the game that hasn't been explained yet.

Kingdom Hearts is kidna wierd like that. The story is so complex it can't actually have plot-holes.

[Godot 513]

So far I'm not seeing as much plot-holes as parts of the game that hasn't been explained yet.

Kingdom Hearts is kidna wierd like that. The story is so complex it can't actually have plot-holes.

 

There are a lot of complex stories with plot-holes and KH is no exception. The more complex the plot, the bigger the plot-holes get. but, I digress.