• Log in with Twitter Log In with Google
  •    Sign In   
  • Create Account

You are viewing the forum as a guest. For a better experience, please sign in or create an account.

Forum Search New Content Forum Rules Boards Status Updates Fan-made Images Fan-made Videos Livestreams Chatroom

If I could redesign a game

  • Please log in to reply
3 replies to this topic

#1 Perkilator


    R.I.P Luigi. He never got to try Peach's spaghetti.

  • Member
  • 690 posts

Posted 08 February 2018 - 07:19 PM

If I could redesign any kind of game, it would be a Sonic the Hedgehog game. Sonic the Hedgehog is a game series that was created in 1991, starting with the titular SEGA Genesis game. The most recent entry in the series, Sonic Forces, has met mixed reception and is considered the most mediocre game. One of its main criticisms is towards its level design, which is notably more linear than previous entries. This is somewhat of an issue, because nearly every level can be beaten in a minute or under due to how shorter they are. Also, there are two newbie game designers and a lead designer from Sonic Lost World who worked on the game design. If I was the lead designer Forces, I wouldn’t have made the levels linear. I would’ve opened up more alternate pathways, lowered the amount of boost pads and springs, put less rings in areas they don’t need to be, and have shorter 2D sections. The more I compared Forces to other games, the more I began to realize how much those problems show, and I began to understand why they’re part of criticisms. Sonic Team may be too late to realize this (or at the very least, not realize it very soon), but having two newbies and a guy who worked on Lost World didn’t do Forces much good in terms of game design, and it won’t do much good to future games, either. Take 2008’s Sonic Unleashed for example. The daytime levels have some linear sections, but they were mainly used for stepping left or right while running. There were things like jumping poles, wall jump sections, and occasionally their own gimmick, and little 2D. The nighttime levels were completely 3D, had things like puzzle solving, and made themselves completely open with the idea of walking around, fighting, and searching for collectibles in mind. The near end stage of Forces, Mortar Canyon, is one of the few stages that isn’t linear; this, unfortunately, is semi-undermined by the fact that is less than a minute long, like all other stages. The beta version is much longer than the final version and has more platforms and obstacles present; it takes less than two and a half minutes to complete by just running. One might argue that another popular platforming game, Crash Bandicoot, is just as if not even more linear than Forces is. As a player of Crash Bandicoot, I can wholeheartedly agree. However, Crash Bandicoot at least takes some interesting turns and opens itself up more. It occasionally has bonus stages and encourages you to break open every box to earn gems and relics. Forces, on the other hand, had little to offer at the end of the stage besides several pieces of avatar clothing that you earn after completing each stage. Comparing that with Crash, you can see that Forces at least has good intention to reward you at the end of each stage, but fails, and the placement of the rings doesn’t make it better at all. To be fair, though, Crash gives you significantly less than Forces at the end of a stage, which can count as a pro on the latter’s part. So, in every way I see fit, I wrote this argumentative essay to express my dissatisfaction with Sonic Team’s way of thinking in this area, as they are the main reasons why I would redesign a Sonic game. Sonic the Hedgehog was one of many things I enjoyed during my childhood, and unless they suddenly decide that they don’t care about putting effort anymore, I still put my faith in SEGA and Sonic Team to learn from their mistakes and hopefully do better on their next project.


Just a random though of mine. Who agrees?

#2 AwesomeKHfan

  • Member
  • 1,019 posts

Posted 09 February 2018 - 08:11 AM

If I could redesign a game it would be Assassin's Creed Origins:

-Less repetitive open world missions (go to this camp and kill him, go to this fortress and kill this man and bring me him/her back) every mission is like this it's extreme version of copy paste and the same camps and fortresses everywhere.

-More open world missions

-Less FORCED grinding, this game has perhaps the worst form of grinding I have ever witnessed, you can't do side quests because you are two levels below so you have to travel for hours to find the right animals and kill them and than you have to travel either back or use instant travel but these animals are also high leveled so you have to travel to another city or country side and kill those lower animals to kill the higher leveled animals... Than you have to travel to a shop to buy weapons but you don't have the amount of money so you have to sale the skins and redo the hole thing again and again! You could've done a Kingdom Hearts system style, Final Fantasy style, Witcher 3 style but now it has to be those dumb high leveled monkeys, why am I hunting more animals than killing people in a game franchise about killing people anyway?

-More restrictions: what I mean to say is that Bayek can leave a suicidal woman getten beaten to death for three weeks straight by lions and there are no consencenses hell Bayek doesn't get punished for that BUT KILLING CATS AND INNOCENTS HE DOES? I just feel offended by this personally and there is no need to even complete the missions because the characters don't care.

-The story structure is badly done: the opening takes place normally just like a movie... Than it's a year later and everyone bleeds and the main lead cuts himself to show he hates someone else, he kills the guy we know for one second than he reveals that his son is dead, he is angry, kills some dude than we are flying back to his son's dead than we are back in main timeline and than we wake up in 2017 and than we go back to Egypte in -45 years or so WHO EDITS THIS!

The game also hates you for playing the storyline so you have to grind, when the story becomes actually fun (after hours) the game stops you from playing to grind and this breaks the story pacing ENORMOUS.

#3 Dustin Lübbers

Dustin Lübbers


  • Member
  • 1,388 posts

Posted 09 February 2018 - 11:59 AM

If I could redesign a game It would be Fable the journey 


#4 Weedanort


    "I reflected myself to death" - Weed 2018, in a pub

  • Moderator
  • 6,379 posts

Posted 11 February 2018 - 06:17 AM

Redesigning some old Pokémon games in the shiny department would be easy x)


No shinies for Trainers/Uncatchable Pokémon (I'm looking at you Gen 3 Ralts and Gen 5 Mincinno)