Oh dude, trust me, you've entered a wonderful world, and once you watch even more anime series, you'll fall deeper in love with this amazing world of epic, animated stories! You've watched awesome ones, and there's so many more waiting for you!
I've watched about 70 different anime series, and well, obviously, if I list em all here, it'll take a lot of space, so for now, I'll recommend you at the very least, three!
Inuyasha: It's the anime that got me into anime, and it's about a high school girl named Kagome, and she is one day whisked away into Feudal Era Japan, where she meets half Demon Inuyasha, who's searching for the Jewel Of Four Souls in order to become a full fledged demon! This anime is a classic, and it is badass in every way! Great story and characters, awesome animation, funny moments, epic battles, and amazing music, you name it! I have the entire series on DVD! Well, almost! I have to get the Final Act, which I already watched, but don't own as of yet. X3
Fairy Tail: You've probably heard of this one, and it's about Lucy Heartfilia, a woman who is a Celestial Wizard, and she wants to join the most popular Wizard Guild around, which is Fairy Tail! She gets more than she bargains for, though, when she meets Natsu and Happy, two travelers who change her life forever! The anime is full of amazing characters with epic magic, awesome stories, great animation and battles, and epic music as well! It's a show I really love, and it's hilarious to no end! Don't get me wrong, it's also serious!
Clannad: This one is a different type of anime, since it's more a high school/slice of life show, but I think you'll like it! It's the story of Tomoya, a high school boy who doesn't really care much about anything until he meets Nagisa. Once he meets her and makes new friends, his life gradually changes! It's an anime that will make you cry! Believe me, I did so, and I cried many times! The story tugs at your heartstrings, and it has lighthearted moments, but also moments that make you think about life, ya know? Overall, a great series, and one I bet you'd love!